Friday, October 17, 2014

BAIL / PROBATION / Suspension of punishment


The recent verdict in a corruption case, wherein the convict was released on “Bail” (the terminology that was used by the so called press) by the Hon'ble Supreme Court, literally speaking the word/terminology “Bail” pronounced, whether applicable, is the question behind this article.

Before interpretations, the formal thesis of law like that of the universe  defines that everything has three stages, likewise the array of crime and its punishment’s are divided into three stages, namely Suspect, Accused and Convict. As like all, the terminology Bail has three stages.  The first two stages shall be called and defined as Bail and the third stage shall not be termed Bail, which is the urging point of this article. The interpretation is the first two is called Release on Bail and the third is called “Release on Probation” / "suspension of punishment" (a provision with a limited preview)   - the right terminology that is to be used and not otherwise.

As Interpreted by law and its definition, a Suspect can seek Bail, anticipating his/her arrest, which is Anticipatory Bail (even though the Cr.P.C defines no such terminology “Anticipatory Bail” but still we generally call it so). An Accused seeks the court to release him/her on Bail, on the principle that he/she shall be released on Bail, with or without condition, till the verdict is confirmed by the court, as judgment. The third is a Convict who shall seek the court to release him/her only on Probation but not on Bail or for suspension of punishment". Nowhere in the Cr.P.C can we find the provision to release a Convict on Bail

As enumerated by law a Suspect and an Accused can seek Bail, but not a Convict. The Convict’s only remedy is to seek the court to suspend the conviction and release him/her on Probation. The Conviction of a court can be suspended in two ways, (1) by an application to release on Probation and (2) by way of an Appeal.   

If no application for suspension is entertained immediately by the conviction court, the only option for the Convict is to prefer an appeal and seek suspension.  A note for clarity that just because the conviction order of the lower court is appealable, it doesn’t mean that the Convict is entitled to Bail automatically, that is to procedurally state, if the application for suspension is allowed then the Convict is no more a Convict but an Accused and being an Accused, now he /she is entitled to the terminology Bail.  – A fair definition in my opinion